The way I read this list, the first three are perfectly acceptable alternatives, despite "argument" having a somewhat negative connotation. Even "disagreement" may be regarded as a negative thing, especially since it has been used as a euphemism for a fight. But as defined here, arguments and disagreements are AOK.
Different people have different levels of tolerance for discussion, disagreement, argument, and even fights. I remember several years ago, Andrew and I were having a passionate argument about something. We each believed the other to be wrong. We both tried very hard to convince the other of our view points. To us, this was a totally acceptable interchange. We stuck to the topic and didn't get into a fight. But because it was passionate, a friend actually told me she was worried that Andrew would leave me over this argument! To me, her comment seemed to come out of the blue.
When I mentioned her concern to Andrew, he was totally dumbfounded. Why would anyone think that there was a problem because we each presented the arguments for our side of an issue? My friend has a very low tolerance for disagreement, let alone what we would consider a healthy argument.
I have a very low tolerance for fights. I have deep respect for arguments. And when I say "argument" in this context, it's more akin to an attorney presenting the arguments in favor of his or her client than to the context, "My boyfriend and I got into a huge argument last night and broke up."
I think that as long as people discuss ideas and concepts, we should be able to talk about almost anything. An argument, that is, when someone presents the arguments either against someone else's viewpoint or for their own, helps us learn. They help us see things from a different point of view. If they persuade us to change our minds, that could be a good thing. If we stick to our guns, we may be even more solid in our position than before the arguments were made. Sometimes, they help both parties see a better point of view together than either would have seen separately - that's synergism.
In our household, we have rules posted for fighting fair. I think I'm going to change the title on that to Rules For Arguing, after learning these definitions. The rules encourage sticking to the issues, listening, and looking for solutions. They disallow shouting, hitting, throwing things, using profanity, insulting, blaming, or name calling.
You'd think that we wouldn't need such a set of rules for rabbit shows and rabbit clubs. But unfortunately, that's not the case. I remember hearing two women yelling at each other at Convention last year. I don't know the people or the issue, but it was clear that the argument had turned into a fight. At a show a few months ago, I was afraid that two exhibitors might actually come to blows.
One only need read a large rabbit Yahoo! Group for a short time before you will see personal attacks substituted for making a sound argument.
My hope is that more and more people will decide to use critical thinking, to employ arguments instead of fighting. I'm sure you never thought you'd read on this BLOG that I encourage arguing! But in the context of critical thinking, I really do.
Laurie Stroupe
The Nature Trail Rabbitry “Home Of Grand Champions”
Precious Pet Rabbits
Affordable Web Site Design
I will have just four proven, solid, GC does, but really, I’m in better shape with them. I have three more that are proven that I hope to grand. I have one granded that I will be adding to my breeding plan shortly, and I have three additional does that I want to grand before putting into my breeding program. That will give me eight by the end of the fall, if all goes well.
And I do have a half dozen very promising junior does coming up that may add to my breeding program in the next several months. Plus, there are a couple dozen kits in the nest box right now. And breeding for Nationals is right around the corner.
I am making an exception to the plan. I can’t seem to part with Celeste, Rio’s sister. I want to try breeding them together a couple of more times before I sell her. I like what I got last time. Rio’s such an exceptional rabbit in many ways, that I want to lock in his genes the best that I can.
So that’s the plan and I’m going for it.
I am a member of the North Carolina Rabbit Breeders Association. I enjoy being a member and plan to continue contributing to that club. However, my involvement is limited by the constitution and by-laws of the club because I am a Virginia resident.
Several Virginia residents share my view that Virginia needs a state association. The interior of Virginia is an untapped resource and an underserved area.
I am hoping to find enough interest to start such an association. I have an application and see that we need three or four officers (the secretary/treasurer job may be combined), at least five directors, and a constitution and by-laws. That, with a $25 fee, can get the ball rolling.
What will keep it rolling is a wide variety of interested people with a wide variety of talents. No matter what your talent and interest is, you can contribute to your state association.
Now this is not a complete list by any means, but here are some talents and qualities that a new Virginia State Rabbit Breeders Association would need:
So if you are an ARBA member (or want to be) who resides in or near the Commonwealth of Virginia, we need you. I know you have at least one of the skills or qualities that we are looking for! True, if you don’t live in Virginia, you can’t vote or hold office, but you can still participate like I do in the NCRBA.
Please email me at
And if you don’t live anywhere near Virginia, your own nearby state association needs you, too. Share your talents and skills!
Laurie Stroupe
The Nature Trail Rabbitry “Home Of Grand Champions”
Precious Pet Rabbits
Affordable Web Site Design
I am, if nothing else, a busy woman. But I've filled my life with people, activities, and things I love, so I wouldn't change a thing! My list of favorite things include my husband Andrew, our four children, my Holland lop show rabbits, our long coat Chihuahuas, ballroom dancing, and my cobalt glassware, gifts, and accessories business.
This website is owned and maintained by Laurie Stroupe of The Nature Trail Rabbitry. Copyright 2005 The Nature Trail Rabbitry. No portion may be used without written permission.